Redefining Victory
By wide margins, the rank-and-file members of both the San Francisco POA and the San Jose POA recently approved labor contracts with economic concessions. This was by no means an easy or uncontroversial process. Indeed, acrimony attended all sides of the debate, with some community leaders attempting to vilify the unions for not giving back more and some union members pointedly criticizing their associations, since no one wants to see their paychecks reduced. And yet, these twin votes constituted as sure a victory as any pay raise, strange as that may sound.